I'm on the 2026-27 economics job market!
My JMP, with , and Sofía Sierra Vásquez, asks how including children with severe disabilities in mainstream classrooms affects their classmates' learning.
Inclusive education is the norm: 191 countries have committed to teaching children with severe disabilities in mainstream classrooms. But it is contested, with critics citing costs for classmates, and evidence on severe disabilities, long taught in separate schools, is scarce.
We use records on all Chilean primary school students, 1.1 million children in 4,581 schools. Comparing cohorts in the same school and section, a severe disability in the first-grade class lowers peers' test scores by 2.1% of a SD in math and 1.7% in Spanish, on average. Al
This is comparable to spillovers from groups routinely included in schools, like children with learning and behavioral difficulties or from violent homes. But the cost is not equally shared: classmates with learning disabilities lose 2.6x as much in math and 4.5x in Spanish. A
The source is also specific: the losses come from classmates with intellectual disabilities. Other types of severe disability have no detectable effect, and mixing different types in the same classroom adds no cost of its own. A
Why? We read this as competition for teacher attention. Support staff cover about a third of class time, so the main teacher mostly works alone. Intellectual disability needs continuous one-to-one teaching from that teacher; children with learning disabilities rely on it most.
This points to a low-cost lever: the penalty is 72% smaller in math and 57% in Spanish among children who keep the same teacher. In schools where teachers follow their class as school policy, it is about 40% smaller in math, even though these schools are negatively selected.
No comments:
Post a Comment